Some cosmic clouds glow; others reflect starlight. Difference between an emission nebula and reflection nebula explained

Some cosmic clouds glow; others reflect starlight. Difference between an emission nebula and reflection nebula explained

Confused about emission and reflection nebulae? This is our primer explaining the difference between the two.

Try 3 issues for £5 when you subscribe to BBC Sky At Night Magazine
Published: July 20, 2024 at 7:19 am

In this guide to cosmic clouds, we'll take a look at what a reflection nebula is, what an emission nebula is, and the difference between the two.

The word ‘nebula’ means ‘cloud’ in Latin and long ago, the name nebula was given to any hazy, cloudy object that could be seen in the night sky.

Charles Messier, for instance, compiled his famous Messier Catalogue of ‘nebulae’ in 1781, listing 103 objects, many of which we now know to be distant galaxies or star clusters.

You will often see historic astronomical records refer to the Andromeda Galaxy as the 'Andromeda Nebula', for example.

Emission nebula the Bubble Nebula, also known as NGC 7635, as seen by the Hubble Space Telescope.
Emission nebula the Bubble Nebula, also known as NGC 7635, as seen by the Hubble Space Telescope.

What is a nebula?

Today, the term 'nebula' is more rigorously defined, and refers to clouds of dust and gas in the interstellar medium: the space between stars inside a galaxy.

Those clouds can form in a variety of ways, though.

So when we talk about a nebula, we may actually be talking about a supernova remnant, or about a planetary nebula.

A planetary nebula has nothing to do with planets: it's formed when a Sun-like star, at the end of its life, transitions from a red giant to a white dwarf.

Planetary nebula NGC 2022. Credit: ESA/Hubble & NASA, R. Wade
Planetary nebula NGC 2022. Credit: ESA/Hubble & NASA, R. Wade

The majority of nebulae fall into the category of ‘diffuse nebulae’, so-called because they are vast objects, sometimes several hundred lightyears across.

And diffuse nebulae, in turn, can be broken down into reflection, emission and dark nebulae.

The difference between them? It’s all about illumination, and the clues are very much in the names!

Emission nebula

The Orion Nebula (right) is perhaps the most famous emission nebula. The Running Man Nebula (left) is a reflection nebula. Credit: David Wills, Castillejar
The Orion Nebula (right) is perhaps the most famous emission nebula. The Running Man Nebula (left) is a reflection nebula. Credit: David Wills, Castillejar

Emission nebulae are also known as HII regions, because they contain vast quantities of ionized hydrogen.

These are giant clouds of gas and dust that have at least one star at their heart.

It is the light emitted by this star that causes the nebula as a whole to become visible.

Simply put, an emission nebula is a nebula that glows because a powerful close-by star is ionizing the gas, causing it to glow.

The Lagoon Nebula is another famous emission nebula. Credit: Andreas Papp
The Lagoon Nebula is another famous emission nebula. Credit: Andreas Papp

Emission nebulae are also associated with regions of star formation, so in some cases it can be the light emitted by many powerful young stars that causes them to glow.

Famous examples of an emission nebula include the Crescent Nebula, the Bubble Nebula, the Orion Nebula, the Lagoon Nebula, the North America Nebula and the Cat's Paw Nebula.

Reflection nebula

M78 may be the most famous reflection nebula of all. Credit: Jared Bowens
M78 may be the most famous reflection nebula of all. Credit: Jared Bowens

Reflection nebulae, on the other hand, are giant clouds of gas and dust WITHOUT a star at their heart.

They do, however, lie close enough to a star (or a group of stars) that starlight is reflected by the material that makes up the nebula.

This makes the nebula visible and is what gives the reflection nebula its name.

The Flaming Star Nebula IC405 Shawn Nielsen, Kitchener, Ontario, Canada, 11-13 February 2023 Equipment: QHY268M CMOS camera, Starfield Optics 8-inch astrograph, Sky-Watcher EQ6 mount
The Flaming Star Nebula is a combination of an emission nebula and a reflection nebula. Credit: Shawn Nielsen

Famous examples of a reflection nebula include M78, the Iris Nebula, the Running Man Nebula and the Witch Head Nebula.

Some nebulae are even a mixture of emission nebulae and reflection nebulae, such as the Flaming Star Nebula and the Trifid Nebula.

Dark nebula

The Horsehead Nebula in Orion may be the most famous dark nebula.
The Horsehead Nebula in Orion may be the most famous dark nebula. - ESO

Lastly – and you’ve probably guessed this bit already – dark nebulae are giant clouds of gas and dust that don’t have a star at their heart, and aren’t close enough to one to reflect its light, either.

As a result, dark nebulae aren’t illuminated or visible, and in fact appear on the night sky as dark smudges that block our view of whatever other objects may lie beyond them.

That said, one final thing to note this that all of the above refers to visible light – all three types (emission, reflection and dark) will show up clearly in the infrared.

This website is owned and published by Our Media Ltd. www.ourmedia.co.uk
© Our Media 2024